New article on the regulatory politics of the NetzDG out in TelcoPolicy

I have a new article out in Telecommunications Policy that looks at development of the German Network Enforcement law, likely the first piece of legislation passed by a major G7 country to affect how platform companies moderate harmful content. Here’s the abstract:

“Policy proposals for higher rules and standards governing how major user-generated content platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube moderate socially problematic content have become increasingly prevalent since the negotiation of the German Network Enforcement Act (NetzDG) in 2017. Although a growing body of scholarship has emerged to assess the normative and legal dimensions of these regulatory developments in Germany and beyond, the legal scholarship on intermediary liability leaves key questions about why and how these policies are developed, shaped, and adopted unanswered. The goal of this article is thus to provide a deep case study into the NetzDG from a regulatory politics perspective, highlighting the importance of political and regulatory factors currently under-explored in the burgeoning interdisciplinary literatures on platform governance and platform regulation. The empirical account presented here, which draws on 30 interviews with stakeholders involved in the debate around the NetzDG’s adoption, as well as hundreds of pages of deliberative documents obtained via freedom of information access requests, outlines how the NetzDG took shape, and how it overcame various significant obstacles (ranging from resistance from other stakeholders and the European Union’s frameworks against regulatory fragmentation) to eventually become law. The article argues, throughout this case study, that both domestic politics and transnational institutional constraints are crucial policy factors that should receive more attention as an important part of platform regulation debates.” abstract_short = “An empirical, process-based case study into the development of (and the politics behind) the NetzDG.”

The paper is the result of more than a year of fieldwork in Berlin, and I’m indebted to my colleagues at the Weizenbaum and Humboldt Internet Institutes for their gracious support while I was researching it.


Gorwa, Robert. 2021. ‘Elections, Institutions, and the Regulatory Politics of Platform Governance: The Case of the German NetzDG.’ Telecommunications Policy 45 (6). doi:10.1016:j.telpol.2021.102145.